To cull a shoot in Lightroom Classic, open the photos in the Library module and go through them twice. In the first pass, press P to flag a photo as a Pick or X to mark it as a Reject. In the second pass, look only at your Picks and compare similar frames side by side.
Culling means choosing which photos to keep before you edit. It saves editing time, and it helps you see the shoot as a set instead of one frame at a time.
Compare the framing, the flowers and the light as you choose the photos to keep.
Copy and back up before you start
Put the files somewhere safe before you make any choices. Copy them from the card to a folder on your computer, then copy that folder to a second drive. Jordan's before-you-edit lesson puts this backup ahead of any editing, and the order makes sense: a Reject flag is a choice you can change, but a lost file isn't.
Then bring the folder into Lightroom Classic. In the Import window, choose the folder and pick Add. Adobe's guide to importing from a hard drive says Add keeps the photo files in their current location. If you are still deciding which Lightroom app to use, the Lightroom or Lightroom Classic lesson covers that first.
Pass one: Pick, Reject or leave it
Open the first photo large in Loupe view. Look at it for a moment, then make one of three choices:
- Pick (P): a photo you'd be glad to edit.
- Reject (X): a clear miss, such as blurry eyes, a test shot or a frame where someone walked in front of the lens.
- No flag: you aren't sure yet. Leave it and move on.
Hold Shift while you press P or X, and Lightroom Classic sets the flag and moves to the next photo. Adobe's flag, label and rate guide lists these keys and the U key for removing a flag.
Keep this pass quick. Don't choose between five similar smiles yet. Your job here is to sort the obvious keepers from the obvious misses.
Know what to check in each frame
Some checks are technique. Is the main subject sharp where it matters, usually the eye closest to the camera? Click the photo to zoom in and check. Are the eyes open? Is the photo so dark or so bright that the face has lost detail?
A RAW file gives you more room to fix brightness and color later, so a slightly dark RAW photo may still be a keeper. The RAW editing lesson explains why.
Other checks are taste. Do you like the expression? Does the pose feel natural? Is this the moment you remember from the shoot? Both kinds of checks count. Keep them separate in your head so a photo you love for its moment doesn't get rejected for a small fix you could make in editing.
Pass two: compare the close calls
Now show only your Picks. In the Library Filter bar, choose Attribute and click the Pick flag. You'll see a much smaller group.
Find a run of similar frames, such as six photos of the same pose. Select them and switch to Survey view in the toolbar. Survey shows the selected photos side by side, and Compare view puts two next to each other. Adobe notes that flags and ratings are always available under photos in both views.
Look across the row at the same few things each time: the eyes, the hands and the edges of the frame. Keep the one or two you like best and press U to remove the Pick flag from the rest. If you want to rank the final group, press a number from 1 to 5 to add star ratings.
Decide what happens to Rejects
A Reject flag doesn't remove the file. Rejected photos stay in the catalog and appear dimmed in Grid view. You can leave them there, or remove them later once your backups are done and you're sure of your choices.
There's no correct number of keepers. A portrait session and a birthday party will give you very different results. What matters is that each Pick earns its place in the set.
Practice on one short shoot
- Choose a shoot of about 100 photos and back it up to a second drive.
- Add it to Lightroom Classic and do pass one using only Shift+P, Shift+X and the right arrow key.
- Filter to Picks and do pass two in Survey view.
- Write down how many Picks you had after each pass.
Then check your work. Zoom in on every final Pick and confirm the eye closest to the camera is sharp. Look at the whole set in Grid view and ask whether any two photos tell the same story. If they do, keep one.
Questions about culling in Lightroom Classic
Should I edit while I cull?
Try to keep them apart. Editing during culling slows you down and can make you keep a photo because you've already spent time on it.
Can I change a flag later?
Yes. Select the photo and press P, X or U again. Flags are choices, not permanent changes to the file.
What if every photo looks good?
Look at sets of similar frames and choose the strongest one in each. A smaller set of different photos usually tells the story more clearly than many photos of the same moment.